Citrix donated CloudStack to the Apache Foundation, and the journalists that were pre-briefed dutifully reported the end of OpenStack and victory for AWS, seemingly because CloudStack has a proxy that can make it look like EC2.
The usual AWS allies chimed in to support this view, including @adrianco, no doubt trying to make up for accidentally spilling the beans on Netflix’s special AWS discount (the carefully worded non-denial denial wasn’t fooling anyone.)
CloudStack is joining a long list of game-changing commercial products donated to the Apache foundation:
Cloud.com CitrixApache CloudStack AdobeApache Flex StarDivision Sun OracleApache OpenOffice Lotus IBMApache Symphony Cloudscape Informix IBMApache Derby Inktomi YahooApache TrafficServer Nitobi AdobeApache PhoneGap
The Apache Foundation does great work when they start a project or get it very early (like Tomcat). When a company throws a bunch of source code at them, often as much for tax and accounting reasons as for anything else, the outcome is less impressive.
Saying that this is #gameover for anything not using the EC2 API is a little suspect therefore; it’s a strange definition of #winning.
The EC2 API is pretty terrible - it’s much worse than the Win32 API - and we shouldn’t be wasting our energy trying to support it. The Wine project spent a lot of time & effort trying to reimplement Win32, but it was a moving target, and in the meantime the world moved on - including Microsoft themselves. Let’s not repeat that mistake.
The OpenStack API isn’t perfect, but where I find a big enough fault, it’s very easy for me - or anyone else - to fix it. And if you really want better EC2 compatibility, you can improve it (or fund someone to improve it) and it’ll probably get incorporated into the next release: grab a mop.
Now, if AWS donated all their APIs to the Apache Foundation, that would be interesting…